"Roger Maris was as good a man and as good a ballplayer as there ever was. Still other readers say that Mariss relatively short career should not Roger Gil Hodges, Jim Kaat, Minnie Mioso and Tony Oliva were elected by the Golden Days Era Committee (1950-69), while Bud Fowler and Buck ONeil were chosen by the Early Baseball Era Committee (pre-1950), as announced on MLB Network. I dont claim to be an expert but I am a huge baseball fan. A very valuable player indeed. Nothing like that in MLB since I've been watching baseball. For me, Roger is still a HOFer because of the 61 in 61 & the impact of that 1961 year battle between Roger & Mickey. When Is A Future Hall Of Fame Manager Not Missed? Gil Hodges - Does He Belong in the Hall of Fame? It's like the 1974 MVP races where there was no reason to vote for either winner. shrug My mom has a cesarean scar. I was 14 years old and an eye witness to the duel in 1961 between Mickey Mantle and Roger Maris for Babe Ruths 60-dinger record from 1927. | For years I thought that breaking Ruths record all by itself should qualify him for the Hall, but you make a good argument. Thanks for reading and taking the time to comment, David. I thnk Roger should b in the Hall. I'm going to back away from your examples of Kell and Mazeroski and replace them with Baines and Hunter. In 1961, the defending American League Most Valuable Player won a second straight MVP. The Hall of Fame Case for Roger Maris : r/baseball - Reddit Coinflation, Previous transactions: Wondercoin, goldman86, dmarks, Type2. Roger was MVP in 1960 because Yankees finished 2nd in 1959 with Bauer and Woodling in RF and Roger helped Yankees win AL pennant again. I don't think anybody can argue reasonably that it isn't. They shared an apartment with Bob Cerv. Customer Service. But, sportswriters didnt know that in 1960. Honestly I don't care one way or the other. Sorry. The NL did not expand to 10 teams until 1962. By the end of his 12-year career, Maris went on to win three World Series Championships, two MVPs, and a Before then, he was a staff writer for the Dallas Morning News for two years. You don't think Barry Bonds could have hit 73 in 2001 without cheating when Maris hit 61 in 1961? He does not have the career milestones, and his short peak, while very good, was not excellent. Tony Cloninger:In 1966, the Milwaukee pitcher hit not one, but two grand slams in the same game! The hit total would be the lowest of all position players who did not play in the negro leagues. Who is Roger Maris and is he in the Hall of Fame. in fact, it puts me very much in mind of Brady Anderson in the mid 90s. Playing competitive games most of my life tells me that when people can cheat on stuff like this, they tend to cheat. Quick Links: Since it was established in 1936, the National Baseball Hall of Fame has amassed 333 elected members. Among those honored are some of the greatest MLB players to ever play. Yet not everyone makes it into the Hall of Fame, prompting outcries from fans. One hotly debated omission involves former New York Yankees great Roger Maris. But he actually only had five seasons where he qualified for the batting title. Maris named to Hall of Fame ballot What has happened to sports cards in the past 20 years really bothers me. Maris made his Major League debut on April 16, 1957, with the Cleveland Indians. Only 5-foot-8 and 155 pounds, hes still alive at 93. He joined The Times in 2000 as the Mets beat writer. He lives in Connecticut with his wife and their four children. Maybe, the HOF should create a gallery of MVPS and longstanding major record holders( not to mention greatest defensive players and players who were chosen by their peers for All Star games or the current day Outstanding Player Award).Then, visitors.would better understand and appreciate great baseball, and Roger Maris would be well represented in the Hall. Nearly all my baseball knowledge comes from reading Beckett and trading sports cards when I was in junior high and high school. If Aaron Judge eclipses him, itll be quite an accomplishment. His 1961 season was the best of his career, and one of the best seasons of all time. I hate that Golden Gloves are just throw away facts when considering the HOF. Breaking Babe Ruth's single season home run record pretty much cemented his name in popular culture. Why isn't Roger Maris in the Hall of Fame? - Collectors Universe Or in life, for that matter. Oct. 11, 2022 1:44 pm ET Text New York Yankees Roger If that were possible, then how come nobody attempts to make the case for Munson getting in? Im a big fan of Maris and his cards. The excitement was building because Roger was six ahead of Ruth's record total. Have you heard of Honus Wagner, Derek Jeter, Cal Ripken and host of others? Reynolds, a standout hurler for the Indians and Yankees from 1942-54, received six votes from the 16-member electorate charged with reviewing the Early Baseball Era ballot. Should Roger Maris be considered for If Joe Namath is in the Football HOF, then I believe Roger Maris should also be in the baseball HOF. Maris won the Hickok Belt as the best professional athlete of the year and was voted Sport Magazine's Man of the Year, The Sporting News Player of the Year, the Associated Press Male Athlete of the Year and Sports Illustrated's Sportsman of the Year. Unfortunately for Maris he wasn't the people's choice to break the 34-year-old record. Meanwhile, in 1927, Babe Ruth hit his 48th and 49th homers in his 134th game. The whole subject is really sadRoger Maris career got derailed.He got forced by the Yankees to pursue going for pulled home runs too much in 61.Then, after my fellownYankee Fans started booing him in 1962 he , I believe, doubled down on the pulling8 rather than being more of a BillyWilliams (Cubs) type of hitter which was more natural for him.Then, the injuries, finally the disabling one to the wrist at the age of 30. Article viewed iconAn icon to mark the viewed articles Sadly, and bizarrely, the players considered by the various Committees aren't even close to the best players from their eras who aren't enshrined. Another thing about his 61 homers, seeing as how you criticize the players who broke it because they used steroids: Maris hit 61 in an expansion year with two new teams in the league. He earned a football scholarship to Oklahoma, but didnt like campus life and left in his freshman year to sign a contract with the Cleveland Indians. I think what his critics are saying is that his body of work isnt sufficient to be a Hall of Famer. Roger Maris and Allie Reynolds, a pair of history-making contributors to separate Yankees championship squads, landed on the outside looking in as the Eras Committee welcomed six new members to the National Baseball Hall of Fame on Sunday. However, people questioned the legitimacy of his home run record due to the season expanding to 162 games, as opposed to the 154 games that Babe Ruth hit 60 in. As they say in the legal system: I'd rather see a guilty man go free than an innocent man go to prison. Nobody is going to mistake George Kell or Bill Mazeroski for Cal Ripken or Reggie Jackson. Kell and Maz both got in ~ it doesnt tarnish Cal or Reggie in the least. Many other fans wrote that just breaking Babe Ruths single-season record of 60 (in a season eight games longer than the Babes) under intense pressure was enough to qualify Personally, I regard Maris still to be baseballs season Home Run Leader, excluding Bonds, McGuire and Sosa. We didnt mention the NL expansion in the article. Pretty huge accomplishment. That record stood for 37 years. There is no doubt he is 1 of my favorite Yankees. He probably could have stolen 20 bases a year, but his managers wanted their runners to hug the bag. Should Roger Maris (left) be in the Hall of Fame with Mickey Mantle? Archived post. Boston pitchers shut out Maris in the first two games. But if you make a group of "elite" players and include Baines and Hunter along with Hederson and Seaver then the definition of greatness begins to lose meaning. But claiming he is ANYWHERE near Kaline or Clemente with the glove is just silly. Over his career, Reynolds posted a 182-107 record and 3.30 ERA in 434 career games (309 starts), logging 2,492 1/3 innings, 137 complete games and 36 shutouts. When truck driver Sal Durante sought to give Maris the ball he had caught in the stands, the star declined, insisting that Durante should receive the bounty. Excellent article. I believe he needs to be inducted. Frank Howard is a left fielder, but I will admit he did play a few years in right. Roger Maris Elroy Face:He went 18-1 out of the bullpen for the 1959 Pirates for a winning percentage of .947, best in history (with at least 10 decisions). Last Friday, the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum named baseball legend Roger Maris to their 10-person Golden Days Era Committee ballot. Maris would be a very unusual selection for the Hall of Fame. Maris is a case that makes one think about what a Hall of Fame ought to be doing. Maris was a two-time MVP saddled with the reputation of a slugger, and those 61 home runs hung around his neck like a bowling ball. As a Yankee fan for 70 years, I applaud Bob Greenes Cheer on Judge but Dont Forget Maris (op-ed, Oct. 7). But all Roger Maris was known for was 61 swings that produced 61 homers in 1961. The 23,154 roaring fans at Yankee Stadium were quieted. Maris for the Hall. The numbers never lie These numbers are just average across the board. PCGS | I just watched 61 the other day. A two-time Most Valuable Player (1960, 61) and seven-time All-Star, Maris starred from 1957-68 with the Indians, Athletics, Yankees and Cardinals. Maris was elected MVP in 1960 because he led the league in RBI. I've actually changed my mind about Maris. His strongest showing on the BBWAA ballot was in 1968, when he received 33.6 percent of the vote. Why isn't Roger Maris in the hall of fame It is possible that any player since steroids were invented cheated. Baseball never got over it. Thats true. But, Barry Bonds was taught by some of the best baseball players in the world. He was critical for 5 pennants and 2 world series for Yankees. As we show in our 100 Greatest Right Fielders rankings, Evans is well deserving: https://baseballegg.com/all-time-player-rankings/baseballs-greatest-right-fielders-of-all-time/, Mick you have made absolutely fantastic observations. as for the HOF, he had a 2 year anomaly, then was fairly average. The Veteran's Committee elected former Pirates second baseman Bill Mazeroski in to the Hall. Bobby Thomson: His 1951 Shot Heard Round The World that won the pennant for the New York Giants (over those poor Brooklyn Dodgers) remains the most famous home run in history. His 1960 performance was quickly eclipsed, however, by the circus atmosphere surrounding his 1961 campaign. If Judge breaks the record this year, it will be 61 years after Maris hit 61 in '61. Maris did not accomplish that. I don't know who trained Tiger Woods. After 134 games, Maris remained at 51 home runs and Mantle at 48. Collectors Corner | He was a great player for the few seasons he played. It takes decades often for the narratives to soften for the MLB HOF voting members to offer their "peace pipe" & get excellence recognized. But his size doesn't guarantee anything. Coincidence? @CardGeek said: It's likely that nobody in baseball history hasn't cheated on this record. Pete Donovan is a Palm Desert resident and former Los Angeles Times sports reporter. I'm sure he meant god. Sign In. And that lots of people hated him for the rest of his career for having the nerve to break Babe Ruths record. Reputation: 2587. "If I never hit another home run - this is the one they can never take away from me.". Ruth was on fire, hitting five HRs in his last three games and nine in his last 11. As Ive written elsewhere in this book, in the 1950s the Kansas City As were nothing more than a feeder team for the Yankees. While fans largely celebrated Mantle, Maris received hate mail and threats from fans who thought he was unworthy of the Great Bambinos record. Some fans disagreed with my saying Maris does not quite reach the standards of the Baseball Hall of Fame because of his modest batting average (.260), total home runs (275) and seasons (12), and my belief that only Roger Maris, seen here in the 1950s with the F-M Twins, would break Babe Ruth's home run record by hitting 61 in 1961 with the New York Yankees. It's likely that nobody in baseball history hasn't cheated on this record. Should Roger Maris finally be inducted in the Baseball Hall of Fame His Wins Above Replacement in 1960 was 7.5, the highest in the American League. Roger Maris was not the very personable Mickey Mantle type guy. Maris broke babe Ruths single season home run record, but then you never hear much else He was great, but was unfortunately held back by the front office, bitter sportwriters fickle fans and injuries.He would have had lots of seasons like 1960 ( not 1961). This thread took a hard left turn since my last login. Over 1,463 games, Maris logged 195 doubles, 42 triples, 275 home runs and 850 RBIs. It was a special accomplishment. The Ford C. Frick Award is given out by MLB to broadcasters annually. it is entirely possible that Maris cheated on his way to 61 as it certainly was a statistical anomaly for him. He saved the 62 World Series with an unspectacular , yet great, play with 2 outs in the 7th game stopping the fast Giants Matty Alou, running on contact from.first base, at 3rd base on a righty hitting Willie Mays double down the right field line which Maris got to on one hop just before it reached the warning track; pivoted, hit 2nd Baseman.Bobby Richardson with a good,tough throw and Richsrdson was able to hold Alou to 3rd Base (Yankee Catcher, Elston Howard said that they would have gotten out Alou by a lot if he had continued to Home Plate. Some fans disagreed with my saying Maris does not quite reach the standards of the Baseball Hall of Fame because of his modest batting average (.260), He would say later that Durante's generosity meant more to him than the media pressures and the catcalls from the pro-Ruth and pro-Mantle fans. You could probably do the same with 90%+ of those in the hall. I was too young to have see Maris play,but what I have heard an seen,he is not a H O F. If you put Maris in, Juan Gonzalez, Dave Parker and Frank Howard all need to get the H O F ! Why isn't Roger Maris in the hall of fame? This last is simply not true. Last night, Aaron Judge surpassed Roger Maris for both the New York Yankees' single-season home run record as well as the American League home run record. Not sure without looking it up. @reelinintheyears said: If you're committed to voting for a Dodger and won't vote for Messersmith because pitchers have their own award, what is the argument for voting for Garvey over Wynn? Why is Roger Maris not in the Baseball Hall of Fame? So, according to you only people who are alive at the time can comment on history? The most beautiful comment in my e-mail came from Altenir Silva, a baseball-savvy writer in Rio de Janeiro. A The Hawk Soars Into Baseball's Hall of Fame, Latin Born Baseball Players In The Hall Of Fame. If Kirby Puckett is a first ballot Hall of Famer, Maris deserves the nod from the Veteran's Committee. He ranks 64th in BBRef WAR among right fielders. I would think this guy would be in. He was a quiet family type guy that wanted little to do with the press & I think that hurt him! A King Without His Crown: Should Roger Maris Have a Plaque in "He threw me a pitch outside and I just went with it," Maris would say later. Thanks for reading and the comment, Bob. Were Carew's hits, BA, and OBP enough to offset the fact that the Twins finished eight games out? PS: Regarding the Right Field Porch in Yankee Stadium , Roger Maris hit 31 of his 61 home runs on the road in 1961. . Which was very considerate, since years later Billy Crystal made a movie titled 61* about that season. If you watch the video it's obviously fake. That's 40 years of technological advances between the two. @coolstanley said: Scan this QR code to download the app now. Ken Burns baseball docuseries says that Maris started getting death threats and hate mail and stuff when he got close to the record. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. He There have been other Veteran's Committee selectees that compare favorably to Maris. Who is Roger Maris and is he in the Hall of Fame? - Sportskeeda It was one of the most exciting events I have ever witnessed. Spencer. Roger Maris Roger was an outstanding outfielder if you remember the 1962 World Series against he made a play in the rightfield corner holding Willie Mays at third to preserve a Yankee World Championship. While the Yankees lost the World Series in seven games to the Pirates, Maris hit two homers. He recalled Mariss play in the ninth inning of Game 7 of the 1962 World Series, when he cut off Ford Frick was a good buddy of Babe Ruth's he did not want anyone breaking the Babe's record. (As a huge Mike Schmidt fan, I often wonder what he would have done if his career was shifted 10-15 years in either direction to take advantage of expansion/stadium design. Please at least get your facts correct? Maybe also because he was Native American? He would finish his career with a total of 11 home runs. During the 1961 baseball season, I was a 17 year old enjoying my summer vacation before entering my senior year of high school. But what makes you think Chet Lemon would know who belongs in the Hall of Fame? The 1961 and 1962 seasons were unique due to the expansion, which represented the greatest immediate dilution relative to the existing talent pool in the majors and the growing total pool of talent (both expansion outside the US and core population growth). I think it's kinda interesting that his mic failed during the all star game. Mazeroski, Jackie Robinson and even Koufax are a few that might be considered. He and his wife, Pamela, live in New Jersey. also the beat writer for the New Jersey Nets' 1990-1991 season and covered college basketball, college football and wrote for the Metro section. Koufax was clearly one of the best arms in his prime, but his career was so brief, especially considering he didn't hit his stride until it was nearly halfway over! From Kirk Gibson to Elroy Face, 10 baseball players not He then returned in Game 4 to pitch 3 1/3 perfect innings of relief to record the save before New York went on to win the Series in Game 5. Why Roger Maris Thanks for the article. In the end Maris prevailed and hit No. And yet you call yourself CardGeek. Before last night, both of these records were shared by both Maris and Judge for 61 total home runs. Jack Curry has covered baseball for the The New York Times for 18 seasons. Yes, clearly they got every fan in the stadium to react at the same time and be in on the scam. Bo Jackson: Maybe the best of all two-sport athletes. Its highly unlikely that Maris will be elected by this committee in December, but his career should be remembered for more than just his very high points. . Because except for a a couple seasons, he basically was average https://bleacherreport.com/articles/221894-the-king-without-a-crown-should-roger-maris-be-in-the-hall-of-fame. Now it is October 1, 1961, the last game of the season. @CardGeek said: We would spend one season with Cleveland and the Oakland Athletics before being traded to the New York Yankees in a seven-player deal in December 1959. It's bleeding over in to MTG. In 1999 the United States Postal Service issued a commemorative stamp honoring Roger Maris. Roger Maris had a career batting average of .260, and 275 home runs. Born in Jersey City, N.J., Curry graduated from Fordham University. Maris stood out, but many had career years in these two years - Cash, Gentile, Davis among others. I wouldn't say he's more famous than Pete Rose. It was Maris versus Ruth. (In 1989 Fernando Tatis of the Cardinals hit two grand slams in the same inning!). My Man Taxerman, a faithful Yankees fan, also reinforced my observation that Maris was a superb right fielder. Maybe roger never makes it to the Hall, thats ok. Thanks for reading. Roger Maris I think Burns says Maris wished he had never broken it because of the response from the public and probably other players too. By the end of June he had hit 27 and by the end of July Maris had hit 40 home runs. Put them both in. The announcer and the right fielder had no doubt. Successful dealings with Wcsportscards94558, EagleEyeKid, SamsGirl214, Volver, DwayneDrain, Oaksey25, Griffins, Cardfan07, Etc. He had great impact in his era. I admit I wanted Mickey to break the record, but after he was out of the race I was routing for Roger. This blogs regular features, including live game analysis, news and notes from Tyler Kepner, David Waldstein and others, can now be found on the baseball section of our website.Readmore, The free-agent second baseman Robinson Cano is reportedly still seeking a 10-year deal for $310 million, figures the Yankees are said to be unwilling to meet. Roger Maris the Angels for the Riverside Press-Enterprise in California and the Mariners for the Seattle Post-Intelligencer. I collect Steve Garvey, Dodgers and signed cards. He previously worked for the National Baseball Hall of Fame, and Major League Baseball Advanced Media. He did more in a few years than Baines, Simmons, and all other recent entries in the hall of good combined. Read22 hours ago | Mark Penn, Article viewed iconAn icon to mark the viewed articles But, Maris is way, way more famous than any baseball player not in the HOF. Nevertheless, from 1959 -.1962 his fellow American League players (and coaches, I believe ) chose him as an American League All-Star. The arguments against Maris include his struggles with durability and longevity, with his 1,463 games played being on the very low end for a candidate. If you can consider players like Barry Bonds and others who are accused of cheating and using peds and other drugs to get an advantage than you should put players Roger Maris and Pete Rose in the Hall of Fame without hesitation. Many players who were only slightly above average and for a short time were enshrined in those years. At least it still clings to 3 figures, the same seems not to apply about most who have posted here. WebSep 6, 2022 - Lets talk about my dads favorite Hall of Fame case: Roger Maris. Yankee fans and baseball fans should be screaming loud now - perhaps the guys on the Veterans Committee will hear you. I don't even think there's a fair slippery slope case because in 60 years nobody without mostly verified allegations has topped him. To paraphrase: It does no good telling people that Henderson and Seaver were no good. I'm sure tons of reporters covered the story. @nam812 said: Today, no one pitches back-to-back complete games! Ben Shpigel has covered the Mets for The Times since 2005. Why isn't Roger Maris in the hall of fame? - Answers I changed the contrast on this image. in fact, it puts me very much in mind of Brady Anderson in the Now, with Judge taking over the record, it has left baseball fans wondering about Roger Maris' legacy. He absolutely legitimately hit 61 in '61, no ifs and or buts about it!!! I have seen plenty of highlights and video footage. They were games 152,153 and 154. He followed up with a 24-9 season in 69 to win another Cy Young. The guy was the best at his position for more than half his career. ReadApril 30, 2023 | Nicholas Tomaino, Opinion: The Fed Failed but Wants More Power, Opinion: Putin Exploits the Armenians of Karabakh, Opinion: Randi Weingartens Incredible Covid Memory Loss, Opinion: Women in Science Are Doing All Right, Save up to $15 with TurboTax coupon May 2023, Epic Bundle - 3x Expert Stock Recommendations, 15% Off DIY Online Tax Filing Services | H&R Block Coupon Code, 10% TopResume Discount Code for expert resume-writing services, Exclusive Groupon Promo Code - 30% OFF Local Experiences, Trump Could Win if People Vote Their Pocketbooks, Randi Weingartens Incredible Covid Memory Loss, Epsteins Private Calendar Reveals Prominent Names, First Republic Bank Is Seized and Bulk Sold to JPMorgan, Fed Set to Raise Rates to 16-Year High and Debate a Pause, Opinion: The Blue State Exodus Accelerates, Opinion: Politico Aims at Gorsuch and Misses, JPMorgan Buys First Republic Bank in Second-Largest U.S. Bank Failure, WSJ Opinion: Feeling Lucky, Democrats Back Non-Compos Presidential Politics, WSJ Opinion: The Teachers Union Says: 'Don't Blame Us', Why the Fed Raises Interest Rates to Deal With Inflation. His stats, 275 career HR, .260 batting average, and 38.2 WAR are nowhere near numbers to qualify for the Hall. F Craig was a three-time Super Bowl champion and four-time Pro Bowl player. His career beyond '61 and '60 is relatively unremarkable, but to set a long standing record like that in a sport that has been recorded for so long is remarkable and enough to be enshrined. Number 60 came at Yankee Stadium off Baltimore's Bill Fisher on September 26. The record is completely corrupt. in which I wrote that his 61 home runs looked better than ever after a half century. PSE | Similarly, in the AL it's clear that the best performances were by pitchers (six of the top eight in WAR were pitchers), but Burroughs was still a very strange choice. If Joe Namath is in the Football HOF, then I believe Roger Maris should also be in the baseball HOF. But it was only a matter of time before the Yankees would yank him (sorry) from Kansas City. The commissioner, Ford Frick, refused to attend any of the games during his historic chase, and even decided to place the ridiculous asterisk in the record book. His legacy remains those 61 homers, with or without an infamous asterisk imposed by the commissioner of baseball.*. David Ortiz could be voted into the Baseball Hall of Fame on Tuesday, but there will be trends worth noting even if he, Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens and others fall short. Mantle rebutted these attempts to divide the two. Because (1) early in his career he struggled to earn playing time against left-handed pitching, and (2) he was injured frequently. The HoF has never had standards as low as it did starting shortly after Maris retired and continuing on and off for about a decade, and it never will again. You can probably assume that means a HR, especially if that was a statement he used frequently. It's hard to watch average NFL players and even convicts get into the NFL HOF while MLB struggles to acknowledge generational stars ~ in many cases careers like Dave Parker, Steve Garvey and Dale Murphy made the All Star team in almost every season in which they played. Maris is an extraordinary example of stardom. No one broke that 61 HR record until the Steroid Era & sadly those cheaters will probably be inducted eventually! a double by Willie Mays on the squishy turn in right field, holding Matty Alou at third base with the tying run, just before Willie McCovey lined out to Bobby Richardson to end the Series. By ALL accounts over the past 60+ years both Roger Maris and his surviving family were decent, honest, kind, god-fearing people. The dude in the stands has a ball. However, you could also argue that average HOF players gained an advantage from specific feats or a brief stint of dominance, where the career numbers don't quite seem to say HOF career.
Where Can I Use My Health Pays Rewards Card Missouri, Commonlit Answer Key The Lottery, How Long To Cook Frozen Tilapia In Air Fryer, Apple Employee Trading Window, Articles W